Our Ranked List of Male Sexual-Health Supplements (2026)

Introduction: Why This Category Is Worth a Look

The men's sexual-health category is crowded and full of bold marketing. Few products have been tested themselves in a published trial, and many keep their doses to themselves. We checked the five products we've reviewed against what we could verify. Want our two picks head to head? See VigRX Plus vs ProSolution Plus.

For every product, we look at the current formula and disclosed doses, whether the product itself has gone through a published trial, what the ingredient research shows, the guarantee terms and the main safety cautions. As disclosed above, we earn affiliate commissions when you buy through our links.

Why VigRX Plus Is Our Top Pick

This herbal blend for male sexual function comes from Leading Edge Health and contains ginseng, ginkgo, damiana, saw palmetto and other herbs. One small 2012 placebo-controlled trial tested the product. Its own section further down covers the formula, evidence, guarantee terms and cautions.

How to Judge Products in This Category

Before you compare individual products, run through these checks first:

• Doses versus the research: An ingredient present at a small fraction of the studied dose is unlikely to match the findings. See whether the label discloses every dose, then compare each with the amounts used in human studies.
• Human evidence: Look for a published, placebo-controlled trial of the product itself. Most products in this category have none. They lean on ingredient studies, animal data or traditional use.
• Branded ingredients: Extracts with brand names (KSM-66, Sensoril, Cognizin, Furosap and SYN-COLL are examples) are standardized, and some have their own studies, often funded by the supplier. A brand name by itself doesn't tell you the product uses a studied dose.
• Manufacturing and testing: In the US, supplements must be made under the FDA's current good manufacturing practice (cGMP) rules. A certificate of analysis from an independent lab is a helpful extra check on purity and dose.
• Refund terms: Read the conditions, not only the number of days. Many guarantees want containers back at the warehouse inside the window, and they don't refund shipping.

Product Rankings

The ranking reflects our overall assessment of ingredients and doses, published evidence, openness about the formula, guarantee terms, safety and value:

Swipe for more

Rank 1: VigRX Plus in Detail

Top pick: male sexual-health supplements | 67-Day Money-Back Guarantee (seller's terms apply)

Leading Edge Health sells this herbal blend (ginseng, ginkgo, damiana, saw palmetto and others) for male sexual function. It has one small 2012 placebo-controlled trial of the product.

VigRX Plus could suit healthy men with mild erection concerns who want a herbal product with at least one published placebo-controlled trial behind it. That trial was small, short, of unclear funding and used a different, higher-dose formula, so keep expectations modest. Anyone on blood thinners, diabetes or heart medicines should check with a doctor first.

Our Findings

• Formula: The current official site lists eight ingredients: damiana, Asian red ginseng, muira puama, hawthorn, catuaba, saw palmetto, ginkgo and Bioperine (black pepper extract). The dose is 1 pill twice a day. The sales page doesn't show per-ingredient amounts.
• Evidence: One published 12-week placebo-controlled trial of the product (Shah et al., 2012; 75 men completed) found better erectile function scores than placebo. The trial was small and its funding isn't stated. It also tested an older 11-ingredient formula at double the current dose.
• Guarantee: 67-day money-back guarantee. You can try it for 60 days, but containers have to reach the warehouse within 67 days of delivery, "no exceptions." Shipping is not refunded, and each customer gets one refund.
• Cautions: Check with a doctor first if you take blood thinners or medicines for diabetes, the heart or blood pressure. Erection problems that persist can be an early sign of heart disease.

Read our complete VigRX Plus review

#2: ProSolution Plus in Detail

Top pick: men's staying-power formulas | Seller's terms apply to the 67-Day Money-Back Guarantee

Leading Edge Health markets this seven-herb Ayurvedic blend for staying power. One 60-day placebo-controlled trial linked to the developer tested its formula.

ProSolution Plus may suit healthy men whose main concern is finishing too soon and who want a supplement with at least one placebo-controlled trial of its formula. That trial was short and developer-linked, and the herbs carry real interaction concerns. It is not a substitute for proven PE treatments or a doctor's advice.

Our Findings

• Formula: The official site shows no amounts for its seven Ayurvedic herbs, which are Tribulus terrestris, ashwagandha, Asparagus adscendens, Mucuna pruriens, Asteracantha longifolia, Curculigo orchioides and shilajit. Butea superba is not an ingredient.
• Evidence: Kulkarni et al., 2011 (PubMed) ran the only trial: 148 men, 60 days, placebo-controlled and linked to the developer. Erectile function and premature ejaculation scores came out better than placebo. Researchers outside the developer haven't replicated it.
• Guarantee: 67-day money-back guarantee. You can try it for 60 days, but containers have to reach the warehouse within 67 days of delivery, "no exceptions." Shipping is not refunded, and each customer gets one refund.
• Cautions: Mucuna has L-dopa in it. Don't combine it with Parkinson's medicines or MAO inhibitors unless your doctor approves. Ashwagandha may interact with sedative, thyroid, diabetes and blood pressure medicines.

Read our complete ProSolution Plus review

#3: Erectin in Detail

Alternative pick: male sexual-health supplements | 67-day guarantee (terms not confirmed)

Leading Edge Health sells this herbal softgel, which has 10 botanicals (including ginkgo, hawthorn, saw palmetto and tribulus) plus BioPerine, for male sexual performance.

Erectin is a fully labeled multi-herb softgel from an established maker. It may suit men who want to try a herbal option and are comfortable using the 67-day guarantee. The main caveat is evidence: no published trial of Erectin exists, and most herbs are dosed well below what studies used.

Our Findings

• Formula: This softgel has 10 botanicals plus BioPerine, taken as 2 softgels a day. A label listing shows saw palmetto, ginkgo and hawthorn at 200 mg each, tribulus at 150 mg and smaller amounts of the rest. We couldn't confirm that this is the current label.
• Evidence: Erectin has no published trial. Most herbs are dosed well below the amounts used in studies (for example, 50 mg of Korean red ginseng versus about 2,700 mg a day in small erection trials).
• Guarantee: Third-party listings describe a 67-day money-back guarantee, which we could not confirm on the official site. Shipping is not refunded.
• Cautions: Ginkgo can raise bleeding risk. The product contains soy and bovine gelatin, so it isn't vegetarian.

Read our complete Erectin review

#4: MagnaRX+ in Detail

Herbal blend for men, never trialed | 60-day guarantee (terms not confirmed)

This herbal tablet is marketed for male sexual health and lists 16 ingredients, including L-arginine, Asian ginseng, maca, horny goat weed and muira puama.

Men who want to try a multi-ingredient product with a money-back guarantee behind it might consider this broad herbal blend. No trial has been published, the doses aren't disclosed, and we couldn't verify the 'urologist-formulated' claim.

Our Findings

• Formula: Per third-party listings it has 16 ingredients: L-arginine, Asian ginseng, maca, horny goat weed, muira puama, licorice, oyster meat and others. Doses aren't disclosed.
• Evidence: There is no published trial, and we couldn't verify the "urologist-formulated" claim. Small trials of ginseng and maca used gram-level doses, which a 16-ingredient tablet is unlikely to supply.
• Guarantee: Third-party listings describe a 60-day money-back guarantee. We haven't verified the current terms on the official site.
• Cautions: It contains oyster (shellfish). Licorice may raise blood pressure, while horny goat weed and L-arginine can interact with nitrates, erection medicines and blood pressure drugs.

Our complete MagnaRX+ review →

#5: Extenze in Detail

Found in retail stores | Refund terms unverified

A men's sexual-health pill that has been sold for many years, built on proprietary blends of yohimbe/yohimbine, DHEA, pregnenolone and herbal extracts.

ExtenZe is a widely sold brand with a long history. It has never had a published clinical trial, its doses sit inside proprietary blends, and it carries stimulants and hormones that some men should avoid. The makers have settled false-advertising cases over size claims, and a new class action was filed in 2025. If you're considering it, speak to a doctor first.

Our Findings

• Formula: Proprietary blends of yohimbe and yohimbine, DHEA, pregnenolone and a long list of herbs. Amounts for each ingredient aren't disclosed, and more than one version is sold.
• Evidence: No clinical trial exists. False-advertising cases against its makers have been settled, a class action was filed in 2025, and the FDA warned in 2018 that one production lot contained undeclared sildenafil.
• Guarantee: We weren't able to confirm the current refund terms.
• Cautions: Anyone with heart disease, high blood pressure or anxiety should avoid yohimbe and yohimbine. Both DHEA and pregnenolone are hormones, and tested sport bans DHEA.

Our complete Extenze review →

Buying Guide: What to Check

Whichever supplement in this category you consider, check these points before you buy:

• Every ingredient and dose disclosed, with no proprietary blend hiding individual amounts
• Made under FDA cGMP rules, ideally backed by an independent certificate of analysis
• A refund window long enough for a fair trial, with conditions you've actually read
• Buy from the official site if you want the money-back guarantee to apply
• Marketing claims that stay realistic, with no promise to cure anything or guarantee an outcome

Safety Considerations

Every product discussed in this article is sold as a dietary supplement or cosmetic, not a medicine. None is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

Speak with a qualified healthcare professional before you start any supplement, especially if you take prescription medication, have a medical condition, or are pregnant or breastfeeding. Results differ between people.

Final Recommendation

We chose VigRX Plus as our top pick among male sexual-health supplements because a published placebo-controlled trial stands behind it. That trial was small and used a different formula, so keep expectations modest. For staying power as the main goal, ProSolution Plus fits better. Erection problems that persist can be an early sign of heart disease, so see a doctor instead of relying on a supplement. Order from the official site if you buy, so the money-back guarantee applies, and read its conditions beforehand.